Why I Became a Feminist, Pt. 3
by Guest Blogger
I am a man; I am a feminist. This is not the contradiction that it can appear to some people. In fact, I think being a feminist makes me a better man, the kind of man that I can be proud to be. It doesn’t mean that I want women to be superior to me or that I have any less desire to be a man. It means that my definition of being a man is different. It means that I don’t feel domination and oppression based on arbitrary gender roles have anything to do with being a man. I know that what makes me a man is simply genetics; that it’s my choices in life that matter and not my genitalia.
I think I can trace my feminism back to my mother and father, both staunch conservatives while I was growing up. My father was in the military and my mother was very open to being dominated; she would do what ever he wanted, almost without question. Even at eight years old, something about that didn’t seem right. I felt bad for my mom, like she was getting a raw deal. I don’t want to give off the impression that my father was abusive or that he demanded that sort of treatment, but it just seemed to be how it was. At one point, my dad went overseas for a year and my mom took a nose-dive right to the couch, barely moving from her comfort zone. Without my father around she didn’t know what to do; it was during that year that I came to the conclusion, without a doubt, that things shouldn’t be that way. No one person, man or woman, should be so dependent on another person that they cannot live their life without them. Now, I know that what happened to my mother was not simply a function of her devotion to my father, but also as a part of a series of mental conditions she later became diagnosed with, but the impression was still there. Some things never leave you.
My family wasn’t the only formative element in my development, throughout the years, I became friends with many different women. I don’t mean that I made female friends in an effort to have sex with them, although I am ashamed to admit that was something I did in my younger years. But no one is perfect. As I formed these friendships I began to notice the kind of things that other men my age were doing and saying about the women I knew and didn’t know. Women to most of them were nothing more than objects of desire, things to be had and used until they were done with them. Had they taken the time to get to know the girls that they were talking about, they could have realized how much more they had to offer than “ass, titties, and blow jobs.” I began to hear stories from more of my friends than I ever thought possible. These were about guys who would force themselves into a position in which my friends felt that they had to sleep with them. It was rape through emotional force as far as I saw, and it made me sick. I can’t tell you how many girls I knew that would go out on dates with young soldiers–fresh out of basic, full of testosterone, and a sense of entitlement–who would come back and cry to me about being raped. They were all too scared to say anything, because on post (like everywhere) it was always assumed that she had been willing to have sex or she wouldn’t have been in the guys barracks. If she was lucky, the guy would be charged with statutory rape and maybe get kicked out of the Army. At least half of the women I have dated throughout the years have confided in me that their fathers, uncles, brothers, or neighbors had molested them. One in particular had been molested at (roughly) six years old; she still has nightmares to this day about those terrible events. I am thankful everyday that the woman I love more than I have ever loved has never had to deal with that. I hope to someday leave a world where no one else will. Some things never leave you.
In high school I discovered radical politics. At some point most people toy with ideas like socialism and anarchism, or their polar opposites (although I’ve never known anyone to seriously espouse the virtues of fascism.) I read about populist movements, workers rights, and class warfare. I read Noam Chomsky, Rigoberta Menchu, Karl Marx, and Emma Goldman. I came to the conclusion early on that equality and egalitarianism meant everyone and not only a certain type of people. I have marched in LGBT rallies, seen inflammatory political speeches given by some of the most intelligent people I have ever met, and I have sat through class after class designed to teach me the importance of history (all of which were led by women who I could never imagine being superior to simply because they had a vagina). My studies of history have shown me how far we’ve come and how much more work we as a society need to do. Women are still underrepresented in our history books. They were rich and vibrant characters, not just fashion accessories.
I am not the best candidate for becoming a feminist, but here I am. I grew up in a Southern, conservative, military family and spent much of my time in southern conservative, military towns. I am American, white, and male, which makes me part of the most privileged group of people to ever walk this earth, but here I am. I have learned lessons that most men will never learn, because some things will never leave you.
- Ian
—-
The “Why I Became a Feminist” series is open to anyone who identifies as feminist and wants to share their story. Please email me at rottenlittlegirls @ gmail.com and I will consider publishing your piece in this series. I’d love to have a broad range of voices and experiences.
This touched me… A great deal… in our society women still have a raw deal. There are still expected standars and goals for a woman to reach, even if she can have a career she is still expected to at least attempt to get married, and once she gets married she is expected to have children, and in most peoples eyes once she has children she is expected to quit her job, or at least spend less time there and rasie her children… note this a rarely expected of the man. If a woman does not get married she is looked down and shown pity… even if she has abostained from marraige as a choice, sometimes a man is looked down for not getting married but for the most part it is not something society demands as harshly.
wow. i wish i could help every man i know reach the same seemingly obvious conclusions. Thank you for being rational and unafraid of a word that has acquired an inaccurately negative connotation.
Thank you for this wonderful post. I’m going to be sending it on to my boyfriend – a burgeoning feminist currently serving in Afghanistan.
Ian is my new hero.
if you really mean all of that and aren’t just saying something to impress women and get laid, you are superior to at least 95% of men. It’s unfortunate that most of the human race is retarded vermin.
Thank you all for your comments. I will let Ian respond to these comments himself, but I’d like to just mention to “omglookitsagoat” that the writer of this post is certainly not looking to get laid, and I have a hard time believing that “most” of the human race is vermin. That being said, glad you enjoyed the post.
I can say with utter certainty that I don’t need to feign feminism to get laid, that I truly believe in what I have written, and that I am very appreciative of the feedback I have received here.
Kudos to you!
It’s exciting to discover fellow feminists & hear their stories/p.o.v.’s.
The fact that you not only identify with these views but are open enough to share them is great. It’s refreshing (and creates one of those, warm, hopeful, positive feelings deep down in your chest) to hear this coming from a guy.
I’m sure there are many other people (especially guys) who would agree with these same principles, but aren’t comfortable enough with themselves to self-identify with a term a great big chunk of society unfortunately (still… if ever) holds ignorant, negative stereotypes to.
(I meant to say at the end):
Your story may help a lot of them come to terms with their views and embrace the term “feminist”.
I really enjoyed your story. As a teenage girl going to an all girls private high school I have always been taught that girls can do anything. Its so muc that it’s our schools motto. Girls can do anything. I’ve always been raised with that idea of equality and I’m lucky for that. My mom came from a family where there was little hope. She was never taught that she could be a successful business woman. She didn’t have that idea taught to her. She came from a small town and build her way up, to have 3 daughters and put them in a great school and one now in university. I’m so grateful for having been taught that lesson. I personally have never dealt with much sexism. I am pretty confident and when I see boys talking like they do in your story. I am confident to tell them to stop and they will. I’ve been lucky to have been brought up knowing that I am equal. It’s something I wouldn’t have if I wasn’t brought up how I was.
Stop it.
Women deserve only the respect they earn.
If you “elevate” them in your eye, “side” with them in your heart, sympathize with their ordeals, and seek to right history’s whitewash of women and their import, you are just as guilty of chauvinism.
Look at the recent American presidential election. The candidate that was selected, while highly intelligent and surely eloquent, is not “representative” of the gross majority of Americans, if you base it on sex, gender, creed, and race. He still won, though, because he could rally to a cause, and because others could see supporting him as a viable option.
Women cannot do this. Look at the proof of candidacy. Women are so mean-spirited and incapable of respect towards another of their own gender, it is no wonder that after 200 something years, women have yet to achieve the office of President.
There is a reason we have terms like “catty”, “asking for it” and “co-dependent”. It is because far too many women ARE these things.
If women wish to see themselves as equals, it is up to them. Men have no place in the discussion.
Love the blog, nevertheless.
“What makes me a man is simply genetics; that it’s my choices in life that matter and not my genitalia”–I’m pretty sure you didn’t mean this, it seems contradictory. Otherwise, great post. The way that men and boys speak to each other about women can be mindboggling. My unwillingness to speak about women as targets or victims has always made other men uncomfortable around me, yet I’ve only recently identified myself as a feminist.
Ian, I speak the truth when I say I believe you are a very respectable man. As an opinionated high school student, I find myself surrounded by the types of teenagers who have yet to learn that gender stereotypes are not meant to be accepted and encouraged and guys who haven’t grown up enough to treat girls as equals. And I gnash my teeth in frustration at the labels I am subjected to simply because I refuse date any of said guys. I am almost positive that many of the offers I receive are mainly because I am “pretty”, not because they have any wish to get to know me. I hope to one day meet someone such as yourself. Thank you very much for a particularly uplifting post, reassuring me that such people do exist. I’m afraid being in a little bubble filled with studies and the looming threat of college, one loses contact with the rest of the people in the world.
Okay, I hate to rain down on the parade *deep breath*, but can I just say that the other “Why I’m a Feminist…” posts (all written by women) didn’t get nearly the same positive response as this one? I’m not criticizing Ian in any way because I think it’s great that feminism has male allies and he clearly is a strong one, but I think this is representative in the way that male voices are still valued more than female voices (kind of like Obama being regarded as a superhero on the latest issue of Ms). While cousin’s menstruation post may have scared some trolls away, mine (at least on my blog) and dollface’s got loaded with crap. Of course, I could be wrong since dollface is moderating this thread…
That said, it really is a terrific post. There is a genuine honesty to it and shows how regardless of background, feminism really is for everybody. I too come from a conservative home, and sometimes I wonder if conservative homes are the deepest sources for budding feminists (as we often get to see the nastiest sides of patriarchy). Reading, taking classes, marching in protests, engaging with people–these are the ways to addressing privilege, IMO. I also appreciate Ian’s honesty about his personal life, as sexism really does seep into the most private, personal layers of our world. Stories about raped friends and immobilized mothers are not uncommon at all and it’s deeply sad. Sexism is something so many women still do experience today, even in a supposedly “postfeminist” nation.
I do have one slight criticism of one line in the article: “…I am ashamed to admit that was something I did in my younger years. But no one is perfect.” While I don’t doubt the remorse, the phrasing still struck me as rather glib. Felt too much like a brush-off to me.
Other than that, great post. Glad the series lives on! :)
Ah! What happened to my comment?
Okay, so you can basically toss out the first paragraph of my first comment. Geoff proved it wrong. *rolls eyes*
Dolly,
I agree 100% with you when you lament that my male voice has received so much praise compared to the previous articles in the series. I actually talked with Dollface earlier about how I think that the majority of the voices for the movement should always be women. As far as your criticism of my “glib” brushoff, I understand where that is construed that, but it was mostly trying to say that even though I consider myself a feminist I have also fucked up. I didn’t think it was the time or place to have a confessional.
Jt, let me clarify what I meant there. I was saying that my choices in life are what matters in determining my worth as a person not what I have between my legs.
Geoff, I think you really fail to understand what feminism is. No one who is a logical thinker believes that the end goal is to ignore the faults of an individual woman or a group of women but instead to have them judged by the same standards as us men. I urge you to reconsider your viewpoint.
This post is great and just made my day. Thanks, there are still people like you on earth !
Ian,
Thank you.
I’m lucky enough to have a man who thinks in this way in my life.
I’ve been with the other kind as well, and trust me…
It really makes all the difference.
I’m glad that male feminists are a growing community.
It really, really helps in the fight for equality.
Thank you, again.
thank you for posting this. i know so many men that think being a feminist means you’re an angry lesbian, but in fact feminism encompasses so much. i feel it is refreshing that many men openly admit they are feminist, and hopefully many more will continue to do so because feminism isn’t just about women–it involves everyone. wonderful post!
Wow, awesome. Thank you so much for sharing Ian!
Sounds like you also may be a healer. All of these women that confided in you for help when they had experienced sexual abuse.
This is great to read this from a male feminist perspective. I don’t know many of you.
I would also like to write a post for Rotten Little Girls. But, I would probably title it – Why I Have Always Been a Feminist! :)
Cecelia, you totally should!!! ^_^
Okay, I will Dolly! :)
Please do, Cecelia!
[...] top post? Ian’s views on feminism that was published a few days ago. Now, I love any huge traffic coming my way because it gives the [...]
[...] um texto foda-foda-foda, que, se um dia nessa vida maledeta eu tiver tempo, traduzo e posto aqui. Para quem se vira bem com [...]
[...] I realized what different kind of challenges face male feminists. While plenty of the women in that thread were glowing with praise, it was inevitable I suppose that some MRAish idiot would thrust himself [...]
[...] 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, and Part 5 of the series. Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)End of the Week [...]