Thoughts on the Splintered Feminist Movement
by Kelly
I’m pretty new to the feminist movement. While my political leanings have always been liberal and I most certainly have always agreed with the feminism, I wasn’t really very aware of the actual movement until recently. I discussed this in my post, “Why I Became a Feminist,” and to be sure I still have a lot to learn about feminism and what issues are most important to me.
That being said, it’s hard for me to understand the feminist movement because it’s so confusing. When I was in high school I thought it was simply: “Women are equal and shouldn’t be violated or injured by men.” While I still believe this to be a basic tenet of feminist thought, I have since taken several Women’s Studies courses, started a feminist blog that has forced me to actively think about women’s issues, and started to experience life as an independent young adult. All of these experiences have increased my awareness of the diversity of human life – and, inevitably, the diverse nature of feminists.
I understand the differences now between liberal feminists and radical feminists, postmodern and global. When I say I’m a radical feminist, it’s because I have always felt strongly about how women’s sexuality is constructed in society and in the course of my studies have realized that radical feminists and I seem to have a lot in common. However, I’m still a little hesitant to use a specific label. I’m not afraid of calling myself a feminist, but in the few months that I’ve been following feminist blogs, I’ve noticed a lot of infighting amongst “different” brands of feminism.
There are arguments between Marxist feminists and feminists who think MacKinnon is a snotty brat (I read her for a class and felt like she was putting my thoughts to paper, so I’m not sure how to feel when I hear this). There are arguments between white feminists and feminists of color (as far as I can tell, these are often cases of people needing to STFU & L & be respectful but failing to do so). I could go on, but what’s the point? If you read an extensive array of feminist blogs, you probably have a sense of what I’m talking about.
This makes me weary, and I’ve only been on the feminist blogger “scene” a couple of months. I’m wary of starting a flame war by posting my thoughts on sex work or some other hot topic. Apparently, the people I should be worried about getting upset are fellow feminists, not the general public, or men, or misogynists. It’s difficult for me to stomach feminists having huge public fights over which cause is more important or who is dead-wrong about their particular opinions. We’re all in the same movement, right?
I don’t have too many conclusions to draw yet because, as I said, I’m still learning. I hope with time the feminist movement becomes more coherent & cohesive. It seems to me, the more open-minded, respectful, and thoughtful we are with each other, the more we can begin to bridge the gaps between different feminist theories. If we are asking men and women living under patriarchy to question their privilege and their stereotypes, it is fair to ask that of ourselves. I think you’ll find that even though the feminist movement is splintered, we still have a common goal: helping women and dismantling their oppression. It’s something to keep in mind.
- Dollface

Photo Credits
Oh it’s tough for sure. It makes me think about the girl whose e-mail I showed you and how she questioned how much of a feminist *I* was. But I’m actually not too worried about feminism itself. Sure, there are differences between the different branches of feminists but, like you said, there is a common thread that links us all–and that is a desire to end sexism (courtesy bell hooks).
I think this relates back to a Gender Goggles article (I’ll post link in a sec) I read not too long ago too. Often, it seems like the feminist movement is falling apart, but in reality it is the mainstream media’s depiction of it. And even if there is controversy within the blogosphere, I don’t consider it a weakness of feminism but a strength. I believe (if not, I have to hope) that we are a progressive movement dedicated to creating dialogue. Feminsts can challenge each other, and we don’t collapse. We stand on a foundation where controversy can make us stronger; kyriarchy stands on a foundation that crumbles as soon as someone speaks out.
I understand your emotions though (as is probably somewhat evident from my post the other day). There are so many divisive issues like can feminsm be pro-life (NO, IMHO!) and is sex-work pro-feminist (augh, so many mixed feelings on that) and what’s pro-feminist about porn.. Blogging and awareness is tiring, but that is why I think it’s okay to step back sometimes and take a break. We work hard, dollface, to write these posts and to create discussion for no pay! I guess the best way I can think of to deal with feelings of insecurity about the strength of feminsm is to remember what a positive force feminism is and how long it has lasted and what great change it *has* sparked. Even as we sort through our differences, I have faith that that feminists remain unified.
So post about sex work! It challenges us to think about the tough issues. :)
oops forgot the link: http://gendergoggles.com/2008/12/22/a-rant-on-the-failure-of-feminism/
Happy New Year!!! ^_^
Part of the reason I don’t like discussing my specific feminist views is because OTHER feminists start arguing with me. Feels like those silly discussions between various sects of Christianity. You all believe in Jesus, right? Start there.
The feminist blogosphere can definitely be an overwhelming, confusing, frustrating, crazy place sometimes. I like this quote from Rachel Maddow (which is actually about whether she reads her own press and not about feminism, but I think it can be applied):
“But I try not to read too much. It warps your sense of importance and your sense of self. I need to focus on what I think, so that I can stay original.”
Which is not to say that the ESC doesn’t have 10,000 feminist blogs in our RSS reader, and that we don’t love to obsessively read and research certain topics, but at a certain point you do have to give yourself some space to step back and figure out how you really feel about different issues, and not be afraid to go ahead and say what you think, even if you think you’re not informed or experienced enough to be “worthy” of having an opinion, and even if you’re afraid that the ‘feminist police’ will come down on you. It’s really the only way to develop a voice of your own.
@ Dolly — You seem pretty optimistic, which is heartening. I will post about my thoughts on sex work soon. There’s a lot to say on the subject…
@ Lena — I agree! That’s a great way of putting it.
@ EvilSlutClique — Thanks for the comment, that’s a great way of viewing it. So far I have only been hesitant to post about sex work, since that is such a hot topic at the moment, but after considering these comments I am ready to voice *all* of my opinions, not just the safe ones.
A paper you might find interesting: “Who Are Feminists And What Do They Believe?: The Role of Generations”. American Sociological Review, 2003, Volume 68 (August), pages 607-622. The paper notes that there are three separate papers with the exact title of, “I’m Not a Feminist, But …” and others that work along the same theme.